The Interplay Between Mathematicians’ Conceptual and Ideational Mathematics about Continuity of Complex-Valued Functions

Soto‐Johnson, Hortensia; Hancock, Brent; Oehrtman, Michael

2016

Abstract

Adopting Schiralli and Sinclair’s notions of conceptual mathematics (CM) and ideational mathematics (IM), we investigated mathematicians’ reasoning about continuity of complex-valued functions. While CM centers on formal mathematics as a discipline, IM focuses on how an individual perceives formal mathematics. There were four IM notions that the mathematicians used to convey the idea of continuity for complex-valued functions: control, topological features, preservation of closeness, and paths. The mathematicians’ IM tended to be grounded in their embodied experiences and espoused for pedagogical reasons, in preparation for other actions, or to assist their own reasoning. Some of the mathematicians’ IM metaphors conveyed a domain-first quality, which accounted for the domain of the function before mentioning any objects from the codomain. Given such metaphors did not capture the full structure of the epsilon-delta definition of continuity, the mathematicians transitioned to CM language in an effort to make their IM statements more rigorous. Our research suggests that while IM metaphors stemming from embodied experiences can serve as helpful tools for reasoning about continuity of complex-valued functions, one must be cognizant of ways in which the informal IM must be altered or extended to fully capture the CM. Given the pedagogical intent of many of the participants’ domain-first IM examples, we recommend that care be taken during instruction to deliberately elucidate where the IM is incomplete or fails to encapsulate the intricacies of the CM at hand.

Keywords

conceptual mathematicsmetaphorembodied experienceepsilon-delta definitiontopological propertiespathscomplex analysis

Concepts

Mathematics educationMathematicsAlgebra over a fieldCalculus (dental)Pure mathematicsMedicineDentistry

Citation

Soto-Johnson, H, Hancock, B, Oehrtman, M (2016). The Interplay Between Mathematicians' Conceptual and Ideational Mathematics about Continuity of Complex-Valued Functions. International Journal of Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education, 362--389 https://doi.org/10.1007/s40753-016-0035-0

Metadata

Source: International Journal of Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education
Domain: Social Sciences
Field: Social Sciences
Subfield: Education
Topic: Mathematics Education and Teaching Techniques
Open access: Open Access
Citation count: 20
Work ID: W2466041031